1234567891011121314151617181920212223242526272829303132333435363738394041424344454647484950515253545556575859 |
- complex meaning. The above quote was taken from Mark Twain’s The Adventures of
- Huckleberry Finn in the thirty-first chapter. Huck's words in this quote illustrate and directly relate
- with how modern man copes with what Mark Twain termed the “inescapable dilemma of
- Democracy.” In the novel, Huck is faced with the dilemma of whether or not to return Jim, the
- runaway slave, back to Jim’s owner. He, at an early age, is faced with the decision that has plagued
- man for ages: choosing what is morally right, even though it is forbidden in society and popular
- culture. He goes against the fold and goes with what his heart tells him. Huck's predicament is
- Twain’s “inescapable dilemma.” In an essay by Roger Rosenblatt, entitled “The Bill of Rights,
- Rosenblatt ends his essay with a single line: “Downriver we ride together, as ever, free to go to
- hell.”
- Rosenblatt’s final line in his essay makes an important point. It is not just Huck who is faced
- with decisions. Huckleberry Finn represents every person who has ever had to make a decision
- between what they feel is morally correct and what society perceives as right. Today Huck's
- dilemma with whether or not it is right to help free his eventual friend Jim can be compared with a
- doctors decision on whether or not to perform an abortion. The tough decision a doctor has to
- make about abortion is an example of an inescapable dilemma that plagues modern man. In
- abortion, the doctor is faced with a difficult decision. Should he take the life of an unborn child?
- What if the child was deformed, or was otherwise going to be born into a possibly unhealthy
- environment? Is taking away the opportunity to live life morally wrong or not? There are many
- more questions that face the doctor as well as the mother of the fetus. As the mother and the doctor
- are faced with this dilemma, sometimes what they feel is morally correct is not legal- as abortion is
- illegal in certain states. Huck would definitely be breaking the law if he freed Jim. Jim is just a slave
- to most of the people. He is just property that can be sold or used until it wears out. Huck sees
- more than just the slave qualities in Jim. Huck sees life. Similarly many people see life in an unborn
- fetus and have real qualms with killing a developing child.
- Another example of an inescapable dilemma is guns. Should it be legal for man to
- have the power to purchase such an item whose sole purpose is to drain life in general and human
- life? With the many stories of accidents because of children experimenting with guns, safety is an
- important issue. America is a free country though, and the Second Amendment under the
- Constitution, though a limited amendment, allows citizens the right to bear arms. So is this
- amendment morally correct? Equally, Huck has been raised to think that slaves are merely niggers
- who aren't equal, but Huck is also a man of nature and sees all squirrels as squirrels, and all people
- as people. Huck knows Jim is more than others say he is, and he isn't about to let Jim lead a life of
- cruelty because there are other people who think they are better because they have lighter skin than
- Jim.
- Modern man deals with dilemmas such as these with anguish and frustration.
- Modern man has found a way to try to solve his problems, mostly through petitions, rallies,
- picketing, and writing letters to Congressmen. Would one expect to see Huckleberry Finn writing
- an angry letter to his Congressman? Would one see him picketing Jim’s master’s house in Hannibal
- because he didn’t support slavery? It is highly unlikely. Instead, Huck simply tears up his note and
- utters the famous quote that was quoted in the first sentence of this essay. Huck makes a decision in
- himself that goes against society. He does not wait. Huck simply takes the situation into his own
- hands. That is what makes him different from modern man.
- According to Rosenblatt, modern man needs to be more like Huckleberry Finn. Modern
- man needs to simply decide whether an action is morally correct or not, and act on his decision be it
- legal or illegal. Huck proved that actions speak louder than words by ripping up his note to Miss
- Watson. Thus, modern man needs to rip up his letters to Congressmen, throw away his signs for
- picketing, and do what is morally correct; because that is the only way to cope with the
- “inescapable dilemma of Democracy.”
- Huck fights the power of the all-powerful society. After Huck tears up the letter he is about to send
- Miss Watson, Huck is struck with a sudden guilt. It was awful thoughts and awful words, but they
- was said. And I let them stay said... The guilt does not phase him though. Huck is willing to give
- up his afterlife for Jim's freedom now. To me, there could not be a more compassionate deed.
- Huck's unselfishness is something we could all stand to follow. Lessons can undoubtedly be learned
- from The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.
- <br><br>
- Words: 865
|