hce28.txt 10 KB

123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687888990919293949596979899100101102103104105106107108109110111112113114115116117118119120121122123124125126127128129130131132133134135136137138139140141142143144145146147148149
  1. China Paper
  2. CHINESE SOCIETY
  3. Even since the dramatic post-1949 changes in China regarding the role of women, China has remained paternalistic in it's attitudes and social
  4. reality. The land reform, which was intended to create a more balanced
  5. economic force in marriage, was the beginning of governmental efforts to
  6. pacify women, with no real social effect. Communist China needed to address the woman question. Since women wanted more equality, and equality is doled out from the hands of those in power,capitalism was examined. The economic issues of repressed Chinese women
  7. were focused on the Land Act and the Marriage Act of 1950. The Land reform
  8. succeeded in eliminating the extended family's material basis and hence,
  9. its potential for posing as a political threat to the regime. Small-plots
  10. were redistributed to each family member regardless of age or sex; and land
  11. reform provisions stipulated that property would be equally divided in the
  12. case of divorce. Nonetheless, their husbands effectively controlled land
  13. allotted to women. Patriarchal familial relationships in the Confucian
  14. tradition seemed to remain intact.
  15. The Marriage Law of 1950 legalized marriage, denounced patriarchal
  16. authority in the household and granted both sexes equal rights to file for
  17. divorce. The second and most prominent element of the strategy was
  18. integrating women into economic development. Women's employment was viewed
  19. as a prerequisite for emancipation from bourgeois structures as embodied in
  20. the patriarchal family. Furthermore, at the core of the CCP's strategy for
  21. political consolidation was economic reconstruction and rural development.
  22. The full participation of women was not only an ideological imperative but
  23. a pragmatic one. Third, the All-China Women's Federation (W.F.) was
  24. established by the CCP to mobilize women for economic development and
  25. social reform. Women did succeed in gaining materialisticly.
  26. However, culture dictates whether these governmental attempts can be
  27. successful and China has proven that they were only panaceas for the real
  28. issue. Materialistic approaches could not shadow the issue of the view in
  29. Chinese society of the role of women. In the struggle for equality, China
  30. did not go to the women to find what they believed to be the most effective
  31. answer to the issue. The paternalistic powers gave women what they thought
  32. they needed for an equalizer, not understanding the need for
  33. self-affirmation and independence.
  34. The issue the women rallied under was that men were answering the woman
  35. question. Women's organizations were not allowed their voice, which became
  36. an ironic and frustrating endorsement to the pathetic state of women in
  37. China.
  38. The One-Family, One-Child policy launched in 1979 has turned reproduction
  39. into an area of direct state intervention. The new regime under Deng made
  40. the neo-Malthusian observation that the economic gains from reform were
  41. barely sufficient to accommodate a population of one billion, given the
  42. natural population growth rate of 1.26 percent, much less provide a base
  43. for advanced industrial development. The One-Family, One-Child campaigns
  44. have therefore targeted women to limit their childbearing as a patriotic
  45. duty.
  46. The family planning policy is implemented by local units of the W.F.,
  47. barefoot doctors and health workers who are mainly women. Each family is
  48. visited individually by members of the local family planning committee.
  49. After the first child, women are awarded a one-child certificate that
  50. entitles them to a number of privileges. Standard regulations concerning
  51. the type of birth control method employed require IUDs after one child,
  52. sterilization after the second one and abortion for unapproved pregnancies.
  53. The policy rests on a coercive system of sanctions and rewards. Economic
  54. sanctions include: payment of an excess child levy as compensation to the
  55. state for the cost of another child to the country; reduction in the
  56. family's grain ration (or higher prices) for producing a surplus child;
  57. limitations on additional land for private plots and the right to
  58. collective grain in times of flood and drought; and ineligibility for
  59. promotion for four years, demotion, or reduction in wages (Anders,52).
  60. Moreover, the offending couple has to bear all expenses for medical care
  61. and education of excess children, and extra children have the lowest
  62. priority in admission to kindergarten, school and medical institutions.
  63. In contrast, one-child families are entitled to many privileges including
  64. monthly or annual cash subsidies for health or welfare until the child
  65. reaches fourteen years of age; and additional private plots from the
  66. commune. Single children are entitled to free education, health services,
  67. and priority in admission to nurseries, schools and hospitals. Parents
  68. receive an additional subsidy to their old age pension (Croll,89).
  69. The basis for the issue is ironical again. Population growth is generally
  70. the result of a well functioning society. Improved medicine and nutrition
  71. has sustained a higher life expectancy. Internal peace in China has also
  72. contributed to the individuals living longer. Since Communism rests on the
  73. doling out of commodities and benefits based on the number in a household,
  74. the structure of the government itself encouraged population growth.
  75. The rural resurgence produced the natural effect of having more children to
  76. help with the work and produce more. Lack of space in Urban area's induced
  77. pressure on couples not to have more children. A satisfying compromise was
  78. never reached between the two mitigating factors of urban and rural family
  79. needs. Thus, an ineffective initiative was implemented.
  80. Due to the ineffectiveness of the law, compliance became a problem,
  81. especially in the rural areas. Women were looked to for the solution to
  82. the problem. Forced sterilization and abortions were becoming commonplace
  83. in the regions where pressure was put on the officials to take action.
  84. Threats of violence and the loss of assets of a family were gorilla tactics
  85. used on the offenders of non-compliance.
  86. The self-esteem of Chinese women and girls was all but crushed with being
  87. looked at as worthless, since boys were highly valued in single family
  88. homes. Girls were to be for the use of others. In attempts to save money,
  89. girls were kept away from school and provided cheap domestic labor instead.
  90. It is obvious to see the cultural battle that women in China have before
  91. them. The demands of rural agricultural labor undermine the one-child law
  92. and create conflict on many levels in both rural and urban China.
  93. While it is easy to belabor the oppression of women in China, one must look
  94. to the monumental strides that a Communist nation was able to take in the
  95. last 50 years. An unparalleled determination rested in the Communists goal
  96. for answering the woman question. The strides that were taken
  97. economically have contributed to the betterment of many Chinese women.
  98. Communist China's intentions were to provide women with economic
  99. equalization which shook the foundation of Chinese society. The
  100. male-dominated household was being challenged to recognize the legitimate
  101. other half. Remembering that girls were considered useless, brings to
  102. light the true strides that have advanced Chinese society in the form of
  103. legal recognition.
  104. The intra-familial relations have not evolved along the lines of
  105. recognition of the individuality and authenticity of women. For example,
  106. the barbaric practice of foot binding, which rendered a woman powerless to
  107. be an economic contributor. And even beyond that, the twist in idealizing
  108. something so demeaning to women demonstrated that China was not ready to
  109. release their cultural bonds on women. Arranged marriages offered nothing
  110. for women in as far as emotional release. The more estranged a husband and
  111. wife were, the more beneficial for the husbands mother. Wealthy husbands
  112. were allowed concubines while the poor men merely had affairs.
  113. This is not meant to imply that the state and the household are monolithic
  114. agents in an overdetermined system of patriarchy. Although male-domination
  115. persists, socialist ideology raised the consciousness of women to the
  116. existence of their subordinate social valuation. Women did not receive as
  117. many work points as men for comparable labor in the agricultural commune.
  118. Women were encouraged to contribute more to farm work so that men could
  119. pursue more important forms of production. Women were recruited for
  120. political activities but then expected to fulfill their domestic
  121. responsibilities and serve the patriarchal interests of the state. In each
  122. case there were women who attempted to challenge the privileged status of
  123. men. But then there were also women enlisted by the party-state to reorient
  124. the terms of equality under socialism. In an ironic recognition of the
  125. intersubjective synergy between the patriarchal state and household,
  126. Zhongguo Funü (Women of China) wrote the following in response to the
  127. resistance of rural women cadres to housework:
  128. Family and state are interdependent and interrelated. For this reason, in
  129. China home work and social labor are mutually geared together, and home
  130. work is just a part of social labor and plays an important part in
  131. socialist construction....If a woman can integrate what little she can do
  132. into the great cause of socialist construction and if she has the ideal of
  133. working for the happiness of future generations, she would be a noble
  134. person, a woman of benefit to the masses, a woman of communist
  135. morality (Anders,46).
  136. Women in China must still adhere to the traditional roles set about by
  137. their culture. The Communist Revolution provided the examination of the
  138. roles of women in China and implemented important steps toward the
  139. recognition of their legitimacy. Rightly so, Chinese feminists are not
  140. satisfied with their place in society and campaign for a new and better
  141. understanding of the value of women in society.
  142. <br><br><b>Bibliography</b><br><br>
  143. Andors, Phyllis. The Unfinished Liberation of Chinese Women. Bloomington:
  144. Indiana University Press, 1983.
  145. Croll, Elisabeth. Chinese Women Since Mao. Armonk: M.E. Sharpe, 1983.
  146. <br><br>
  147. Words: 1574